Polly’s Pies Menu Prices

If you are looking for a great place to eat in town, look no further than Polly’s Pies Restaurant.  The menu features something for everyone, including pizza, pasta, and sandwiches.

But the real star of the show is the pie. Polly’s Pies Restaurant is known for its award-winning pies, which are made from scratch with fresh ingredients.

Polly’s Pies Restaurant is a family-owned and operated establishment that is known for its delicious food. The restaurant has a wide variety of pies on its menu, as well as other dishes such as burgers, sandwiches, and salads.

All of the food at Polly’s Pies is made from scratch using quality ingredients. Polly’s Pies Restaurant is a popular spot for lunch in the Mount Vernon area.

The restaurant has a wide variety of food menus, including traditional pies and pastries, as well as burgers and sandwiches. There are also many vegetarian options, The prices are reasonable, and the food is always fresh and delicious.

The restaurant specializes in pies, ice cream and other desserts. All of the menu items are made from scratch using quality ingredients. There are a variety of pies to choose from, including fruit pies, chocolate pie, pumpkin pie and many more.

In addition to the delicious food, Polly’s also offers a wide selection of ice cream flavors and toppings. Whether you’re looking for something sweet or savory, Polly’s has you covered! Check out Polly’s Pies Menu Prices.

Polly’s Pies Menu Prices In 2024


Sparkling WineFull Bottle – $19.79
Mimosa for 4$27.49
310 Blonde Ale$5.99
OneHope Brut Split$7.29

Polly’s Gourmet Coffee Bar

Cafe Au Lait$4.49
Caramel Macchiato$4.99
Chai Tea Latte$4.99
Chocolate Silk Pie Latte$5.79
Red Eye$4.49
Ruby Joy’s Hot Cocoa$3.79


Cold Brew$4.49
Polly Palmer$4.49
Strawberry Lemonade$4.49
Arnold Palmer$3.99
Freshly Brewed Mango Iced Tea$3.79
Freshly Brewed Iced Tea$3.79
Soft Drink$3.29
Orange Juice$3.99
Martinelli Apple Juice$3.99
The Republic of Tea Specialty Hot Teas$3.99
Low-Fat Milk$3.79
Chocolate Milk$3.79
Hot Chocolate$3.79
Polly’s Gourmet Coffee$3.99

Pie Slices

Apple Pie$4.99
Apple Pie No Sugar Added$4.99
Banberry Pie$5.49
Banana Cream Pie$5.29
Chocolate Cream Pie$5.29
Boysenberry Pie$4.99
Lemon Meringue$5.29
Uncle Eddie’s Apple Pie Delight$5.49

Bake at Home Pies & Quiche

Frozen-Apricot PieWhole – $15.99
Frozen-Blueberry PieWhole – $15.99
Frozen-Peach PieWhole – $15.99
Frozen-Quiche Lorraine$19.79
Frozen-Rhubarb PieWhole – $15.99

Whole Pies

Apple Pie$16.49
Apple Pie No Sugar Added$17.49
Banberry Pie$18.29
Banana Cream Pie$16.49
Chocolate Cream Pie$16.49
Boysenberry Pie$16.99
Lemon Meringue Pie$15.99
Coconut Cream Pie$16.49
Strawberry Lemonade Pie$18.79


Cinnamon Rol2 Pack – $7.29
Blueberry Muffin4 Pack – $7.29
Bran Muffin4 Pack – $7.29
Dinner Roll6 Pack – $3.29
12 Pack – $5.49
Kracked Wheat Loaf$6.49
Raisin Walnut Loaf$7.79
Rye Bread Loaf$5.49
Sourdough Loaf$5.49
White Bread Loaf$5.49
Cornbread Pan$5.49
Chocolate Chip Cookies15 Pack – $10.49
Oatmeal Raisin Cookies15 Pack – $10.49

Breakfast Sides

Bacon3 Strips – $3.99
Breakfast Potatoes$2.79
Fruit Cup$3.29
Sausage3 Links – $3.99

Polly’s Jr. Breakfast

Egg & Toast$3.29
French Toast Dippers & Egg$3.29
Mini Pancakes & Egg$3.29
Silly Face Pancake$3.29


2-3-1 Combo$10.99
One Egg Combo$9.79
Eggs & Potatoes$8.79
Chicken Fried Steak & Eggs$13.79
Banana Macadamia Nut Pancakes$11.99
Double Buttermilk Pancakes$10.49
Ms. Polly’s Triple Breakfast Suprise$15.49
French Toast Combo$10.79
Giant Cinnamon Roll French Toast$11.99
ABC Omelette$13.99
Fiesta Omelette$11.99
Polly’s Own Avocado & Egg Toast$10.99
Breakfast Sandwich$11.79
Breakfast Burrito$13.29
Have it All Skillet$13.99

Aloha Specials

Hawaiian Loco Moco$12.99
Hawaiian Muffin$3.99
Coconut Cold Brew$5.49
Huckleberry Lemonade$3.99

About Polly’s Pies

In conclusion, Polly’s Pies is a company with a rich history that has been around for over 30 years. The company was founded by Eddie and Don Sheldrake, and they continue to be involved in the business to this day.

Polly’s Pies is known for their delicious pies, and they have won numerous awards for their products. If you’re looking for a great pie to enjoy, be sure to check out Polly’s Pies!

The Polly’s Pies restaurant opened in the early 1900s in a small town in upstate New York. It became a popular tourist destination, and during its peak years the restaurant served over 10,000 pies per day.

In 1974, the proprietor retired and sold the business to a new family. The restaurant closed in 2002 but reopened briefly as a pizzeria in 2006. In 2014, Polly’s Pies Restaurant was permanently closed after being damaged by flooding during Superstorm Sandy.

Polly’s Pies is a favorite restaurant among locals and tourists alike. The restaurant has been in operation for over 50 years and serves delicious pies, cakes, and coffee.

The restaurant is also known for its friendly staff and warm atmosphere. The food is great, but the company you keep while eating it makes the experience that much better.

I have never had a bad meal there and the service is always wonderful. The prices are very reasonable, especially for the quality of food you receive.

It’s the perfect place to go with friends or family, and I would highly recommend it to anyone looking for a good time. Polly’s Pies is a long-standing establishment in the heart of downtown.

Originally known as The Pie Shop, Polly’s was founded in 1912 by Polly and Leo Kaminski. Today, the restaurant features pies from its wood-fired oven, as well as salads, sandwiches, and desserts.

In addition to its namesake pies, Polly’s is also well-known for its cinnamon rolls and waffles – two items that are not on the regular menu but are made fresh daily and enjoyed by customers who know to ask for them.

Popular Restaurant Menus:

Leave a Comment